NatunaFiles

Data

The Vanishing Tender: Indonesia Has Halved Its Open Tenders in Three Years

Half of Indonesia's open public tenders disappeared between 2022 and 2025. The money moved to the e-katalog and to direct appointments, where there is no open contest, and the public record of what was bought, at what price and whether it was paid, got thinner.

In 2022, Indonesian ministries, agencies and regional governments put 107,041 contracts out to open tender on the country’s LPSE procurement portals. In 2025 they put out 50,078.

The fall is not a quirk of one portal or one ministry. On the 483 LPSE portals for which we have a complete record in every year, tenders fell by exactly half, from 98,161 to 49,154. Inaproc, the national procurement register run by the procurement agency LKPP, tells the same story from a separate set of records: the number of packages it lists as awarded by tender fell from 82,222 to 40,683, down 51 percent.

The work did not disappear with the tenders. Most of it moved into the e-katalog, the government’s online catalogue, where an official picks a listed product or service and orders it from the seller. Some of it moved into direct appointment, where an official chooses the contractor outright. Neither involves an open contest that any company can enter and the public can follow.

This analysis follows that shift across every ministry and region for which data is available, using about 2.2 million tender records and 33 million bids scraped from the LPSE portals, and 22.6 million procurement packages from Inaproc.

Half the tenders, gone

Bar chart of open tenders per year from 2021 to 2025, split into central and regional government. The total falls from 122,383 in 2021 to 50,028 in 2025.
Open tenders announced on the LPSE portals per budget year. Tender, selection (seleksi) and fast tender only; direct procurement is not counted. Source: LPSE tender records, NatunaFiles analysis.

Central government, which covers ministries, agencies and state universities, ran 26,301 open tenders in 2022 and 9,068 in 2025, a fall of two-thirds. Regional governments, which run most tenders because they build most of the country’s small roads, schools and drains, went from 80,341 to 40,960.

The steepest single year was 2025. That was the year two things happened at once. From 1 January, all government buyers had to use version 6.0 of the e-katalog for anything listed there, under an LKPP circular issued in December 2024.1 Three weeks later, Presidential Instruction (Inpres) 1/2025 ordered Rp306.69 trillion of spending cuts, freezing many budgets in the first months of the year.2 Tender announcements in January to April 2025 were less than half of what they had been a year earlier, and the rest of the year did not make up the gap.

The catalogue took over

Line chart of the e-purchasing share of procurement value from 2022 to 2025. Regional government rises from 29 percent to 64 percent; central government rises from 18 percent to 55 percent in 2024 and falls to 44 percent in 2025.
E-purchasing value as a share of e-purchasing plus tender value. The 2022 points (hollow) are the least reliable, because Inaproc under-records 2022 packages. Source: Inaproc realisasi, NatunaFiles analysis.

Measured by money rather than by number of contracts, the shift is just as sharp. In 2022, e-purchasing made up 29 percent of what regional governments spent through tenders and e-purchasing combined. In 2025 it made up 64 percent. In 95 of 517 regional governments the share was 90 percent or more.

Central government peaked at 55 percent in 2024. Its 2025 figure dropped back to 44 percent, but not because ministries went back to tendering: the number of central tenders kept falling. A handful of very large tendered works at the Public Works ministry and at the new-capital authority OIKN pushed the tender total up.

The pattern holds across nearly every ministry.

Bar chart of the change in open tenders between 2022 and 2025 for 26 central ministries and agencies. Almost all bars are negative, from minus 25 percent for the law and human rights ministries to minus 100 percent for the food and drug agency BPOM. Two bars are positive: Desa PDTT plus 121 percent and Kejaksaan plus 207 percent.
Change in open tenders, 2022 to 2025, for the 24 central bodies that ran the most tenders in 2022, plus the two that increased, with tender counts. Ministries split in late 2024 are combined with their successors. Source: LPSE tender records, NatunaFiles analysis.

The transport ministry ran 2,039 open tenders in 2022 and 235 in 2025. The health ministry went from 1,451 to 271, agriculture from 536 to 61, fisheries from 439 to 31. The food and drug agency BPOM ran 259 tenders in 2022 and one in 2025. The manpower ministry and the search-and-rescue agency Basarnas ran two each.

Only two large spenders went the other way. The Attorney General’s Office (Kejaksaan) tripled its tenders, from 75 to 230. The villages and transmigration ministries, split into two in late 2024, went from 149 to 329.

Everything is a catalogue item now

The e-katalog was built for things with a list price: laptops, vaccines, office chairs, cars. That is no longer what it sells.

E-katalog 6.0 added a construction catalogue. In 2025, its first year, government buyers ordered Rp25.2 trillion of construction work through it, in 11,925 packages. The Public Works ministry alone bought Rp9.84 trillion this way in 599 packages, many of them road and bridge maintenance contracts worth Rp60–95 billion each: the kind of work it used to tender. Its construction tenders fell from 2,222 in 2022 to 739 in 2025.

Other public works went into the catalogue under the label “goods”. The agriculture ministry bought Rp3.69 trillion of land clearing and rice-field creation through the e-katalog in 2025, against Rp10 billion in 2024. Rp2.19 trillion of that was booked as goods (pengadaan barang), including packages worth Rp50–68 billion each named “Pembersihan Lapangan dan Perataan”: land clearing and levelling. Jakarta’s provincial government bought the supply and installation of pumps at Ancol, Rp226.6 billion, as a single catalogue order, also typed as goods.

At regional level the shift can be near-total. Aceh province put Rp2.64 trillion through open tenders in 2022 and Rp187 billion in 2025, while ordering Rp1.2 trillion through e-katalog 6.0. Its LPSE portal listed 1,849 tenders in 2022 and 87 in 2025. Gorontalo province spent Rp595 billion through tenders in 2022 and Rp5 billion in 2025.

Bigger orders, less on the record

Bar chart of e-katalog orders worth Rp20 billion or more per year: 205 in 2022, 423 in 2023, 415 in 2024 and 886 in 2025, of which 556 on e-katalog 6.0.
E-katalog orders of Rp20 billion or more per year, by catalogue version. Source: Inaproc realisasi, NatunaFiles analysis.

The catalogue’s orders have grown large. In 2022 there were 205 e-katalog orders worth Rp20 billion or more, together Rp8.8 trillion. In 2025 there were 886, together Rp39.4 trillion.

A single buyer can now place a trillion-rupiah order through the catalogue. The primary and secondary education ministry ordered “digital learning equipment” (sarana digitalisasi pembelajaran) for schools in a series of regional packages: Rp1.09 trillion from a seller called Master Media and Rp780 billion from PT Zyrexindo Mandiri Buana, in five orders each. Master Media alone took 46 percent of everything the ministry bought through the e-katalog in 2025. NatunaFiles has previously shown how eight near-identical catalogue orders for “LED” screens at the National Nutrition Agency led back to two clusters of linked companies.

A catalogue order also leaves a thinner trail than a tender. A tender on LPSE publishes the estimated price, every bidder and every bid. An e-katalog order shows the buyer, the seller, a package name and a value. On e-katalog 6.0 even the outcome is often unclear. In the Inaproc export we analysed, downloaded in May 2026, four months after the 2025 budget year closed, central-government orders on e-katalog 6.0 had these statuses:

Status of 2025 e-katalog 6.0 orders, central governmentOrdersValue, Rp trillionShare of value
On process110,84934.5957%
Payment outside system49,75115.0525%
Completed47,22910.7618%

“Payment outside system” means the order was settled somewhere other than the catalogue’s own payment flow. It is not evidence that anything was wrong. But for Rp15 trillion of orders, the public register cannot show whether, when or how much was paid.

What is left of the tender

The tenders that survive have changed too.

They are bigger. The average central-government tender in 2022 had an estimated value (HPS) of Rp9.4 billion. In 2025 it was Rp18.3 billion. Tendering is turning into the route for the largest projects only.

They draw fewer bidders. Among regional construction tenders with bid records, 37 percent received a single bid in 2022. In 2024 it was 46 percent, and in 2025, 41 percent. In central government the share rose from 11 to 17 percent, and the average central construction tender drew 6.9 bids, down from 9.1.

Line chart of the share of construction tenders with a single bid from 2021 to 2025. Regional government rises from 34 percent to 46 percent in 2024 and 41 percent in 2025; central government rises from 12 percent to 17 percent.
Share of construction tenders where exactly one company submitted a price, among tenders with bid records. Source: LPSE bid records, NatunaFiles analysis.

Some institutions stand out. At the national police (Polri), 64 percent of the 542 goods and services tenders with bid records in 2025 drew a single bid. At the industry ministry it was 75 percent of 57.

And the competition that remains saves less money. In a tender, the winning bid usually comes in below the government’s own estimate. In 2021, central-government winners bid on average 13.1 percent below the estimate. By 2025 that margin had shrunk to 5.4 percent. For regional governments it fell from 7.1 to 4.9 percent.

Line chart of the gap between the winning bid and the estimated price from 2021 to 2025. Central government falls from 13.1 percent to 5.4 percent; regional government from 7.1 percent to 4.9 percent.
Winning bids below the estimated price (HPS), value-weighted, for tenders with a recorded winning bid. Source: LPSE bid records, NatunaFiles analysis.

A smaller margin can mean the government estimates prices better. It can also mean that fewer companies are competing hard enough to undercut each other. The data cannot tell which. A catalogue order has no such measure at all.

The other exit: direct appointment

Bar chart of the estimated value of central-government direct appointments: Rp2.2 trillion in 2021, Rp7.6 trillion in 2022, Rp2.2 trillion in 2023, Rp5.5 trillion in 2024 and Rp17.7 trillion in 2025.
Estimated value (HPS) of direct appointments (penunjukan langsung) recorded on LPSE by central government. Source: LPSE records, NatunaFiles analysis.

The catalogue is the bigger exit from competition, but not the only one. Direct appointment (penunjukan langsung) lets an official pick a contractor without a contest, in limited circumstances. Central government recorded 1,772 direct appointments in 2025 with an estimated value of Rp17.7 trillion, up from Rp5.5 trillion in 2024 and Rp2.2 trillion in 2021.

Most of the increase comes from three places:

  • Public Works. About Rp10.4 trillion in 767 packages, much of it irrigation rehabilitation handed to state-owned contractors: Nindya Karya, Waskita Karya, Wijaya Karya, Hutama Karya, Adhi Karya and Brantas Abipraya, at Rp100–150 billion per package. This followed Inpres 2/2025 on irrigation, which allowed the ministry to appoint state construction companies directly. The House of Representatives’ infrastructure commission and the contractors’ association Gapensi both asked the ministry to reconsider.3 The same ministry directly appointed Nindya Karya to renovate schools for the Sekolah Rakyat programme, Rp331 billion and Rp210 billion in two phases.
  • The Attorney General’s Office. Rp3.05 trillion in 23 packages. Thirteen intelligence and surveillance packages, together Rp3.0 trillion in estimated value, are all dated between 3 and 30 January 2025. They include a Rp397 billion “tactical digital forensic” system, a Rp303 billion “airborne reconnaissance surveillance” purchase, three Rp300 billion “surveillance systems to identify and catch fugitives” from the same company, and four Rp200 billion “bot-based narrative systems” for regional prosecutors’ offices. NatunaFiles reported on the narrative-system contracts in February.
  • Defence. Kemhan recorded 73 direct appointments worth Rp2.42 trillion. The maritime security agency Bakamla appointed a shipyard directly for a Rp300.6 billion, 60-metre ship “with complete armament”.

The rules have moved in the same direction. Perpres 46/2025, which amended the national procurement regulation in 2025, allows direct appointment for “presidential priority programmes”. Indonesia Corruption Watch has warned that this gives ministers wide discretion to declare a purchase a priority and skip the contest.4

Who still tenders

Regional governments did not all move at the same speed. Of the 359 regional LPSE portals with a complete record and at least 50 tenders in 2022, 226 cut their tenders by more than half and 91 by more than three-quarters. The median regional government ran 59 percent fewer tenders in 2025 than in 2022.

A few went the other way. Of the 36 regional governments that tendered more in 2025 than in 2022, most of the biggest increases are in Kalimantan and Sulawesi’s mining and plantation belt: North Barito regency went from 153 tenders to 589, Samarinda city from 281 to 664, Berau from 271 to 571, Morowali from 178 to 394, and Penajam Paser Utara, next to the new capital, from 57 to 227.

Why it matters

None of this is illegal. The government wants buyers to use the e-katalog: it is faster, it lets small and local suppliers sell to the state, and it makes it easier to favour domestic products, which Perpres 46/2025 also strengthened. LKPP presents version 6.0 as a tool that makes procurement more transparent, and its rules tell buyers that catalogue prices are not final and should be negotiated or put to a “mini-competition” among sellers.1

But a tender does three things a catalogue order does not. It makes companies compete on price for a specific job. It publishes who competed and what they offered. And it leaves a record anyone can check. Over three years, Indonesia has moved roughly half its contracts out of that system. The numbers that measure whether the state gets a good price, such as the number of bidders and the gap between bid and estimate, are getting worse in the part that remains, and do not exist for the part that left.


How we did this

  • Tenders and bids come from the LPSE/SPSE portals: tender announcements (tender, seleksi and fast tender) with their bidder lists, collected from 596 portals. A “single bid” means exactly one company submitted a price; tenders with no bid records are left out, and consultancy selections are excluded where only the top-ranked firm submits a price. The bid-to-estimate gap is value-weighted over tenders with a recorded winning bid.
  • Some portals stopped appearing in our collection in 2024–25. Kabupaten Bekasi, for example, shows no tenders on its portal in 2025 while Inaproc records 385. Headline comparisons therefore use the 483 portals with a complete record in every year, and are checked against Inaproc’s own count of tendered packages.
  • Package values and methods come from Inaproc’s realisation records (realisasi), which list each package by channel: tender, e-katalog 5.0 and 6.0, online shop, non-tender and recorded purchases. Inaproc under-records 2022 and has gaps for some agencies and years, so shares are more reliable than totals.
  • Construction through the e-katalog is e-katalog 6.0 packages typed as construction. The agriculture ministry’s land-clearing and rice-field figures are e-katalog packages whose names describe that work.
  • Central and regional government: provinces, regencies and cities are regional; ministries, agencies and state universities are central. Ministries split or renamed in late 2024 are combined with their predecessors.
  • Values are nominal rupiah. Data was retrieved in early 2026.

  1. LKPP Circular (Surat Edaran) 9/2024 made e-katalog version 6.0 mandatory from 1 January 2025 and switched off version 5.0, with limited use allowed until 20 March 2025. See Biro PBJ Kalimantan Timur and detikFinance. ↩︎ ↩︎

  2. Inpres 1/2025 on spending efficiency, effective 22 January 2025: Rp256.1 trillion from ministries and agencies and Rp50.59 trillion from transfers to regions. Bisnis.com, CNBC Indonesia. ↩︎

  3. Inpres 2/2025 on irrigation for food self-sufficiency. Bisnis.com; DPR criticism: detikFinance; Gapensi: Kontan. ↩︎

  4. Perpres 46/2025, the second amendment to Perpres 16/2018 on government procurement. ICW’s criticism: Hukumonline, 12 June 2025. ↩︎